| 8 January 1872
Dear Sir,
You evidently misapprehend the sense in which I used the word “party”, I used it merely as a convenient term describing a number of men. I never supposed that you or your “continental friends” opposed Mr Hales, or did anything else, from any other impulse than duty; indeed, were I not fully convinced that you are entirely impersonal, caring only for the large and general interests of the Association—which mean the welfare of humanity—I should not have troubled myself to consult you. I quite understand that you “did not invite” Mr Mottershead to stand for the Secretaryship, hence my note, submitting his candidature for your approval; at the same time, I must say I was under the impression, perhaps unwarranted, that you in|tended to support him. But, even if it were so, you are fully entitled to change your mind; fresh circumstances or further reflection might, indeed, make it an imperative duty. For myself, I have not concealed from Mr Engels my opinion that Mr Mottershead does not possess satisfactory qualifications for the post; but I thought, and do still think, that his faults are less grave, less dangerous to the independence of the General Council, than those of the present Secretary. This, if I have read your note correctly, is our sole point of difference; and, so far as I am concerned, I “agree to differ”. I assure you that I share your sense of difficulty in the matter, hence my anxiety that action should be guided by a consensus of opinion. I am informed, however, that, in consequence of Mr Hales known enmity to me, my co-operation with his enemies may, possibly, by those who do not | know me, be attributed to personal motives; and as this would not only deprive me of their friendship, which I value, but diminish my power of usefulness to the Association, to which I attach infinitely greater value, I shall now wash my hands of this affair. I am satisfied that all the points of the case are thoroughly understood on all sides—that was my great desire—and I am now, equally with yourself, willing that circumstances shall, by the hands of others, determine results.
Yours faithfullyM. Maltman Barry
Dr Marx
Zeugenbeschreibung und Überlieferung
Dieser Brief wird hier erstmals veröffentlicht.
Zeugenbeschreibung
Soweit aus der s/w-Fotokopie zu ersehen ist, besteht der Brief aus einem Bogen Papier. Barry hat drei Seiten vollständig beschrieben, die vierte Seite blieb vermutlich leer.
Zitiervorschlag
Michael Maltman Barry an Karl Marx in London. London, Montag, 8. Januar 1872. In: Marx-Engels-Gesamtausgabe digital, hg. v. der Internationalen Marx-Engels-Stiftung. Berlin-Brandenburgische Akademie der Wissenschaften, Berlin. URL: https://megadigital.bbaw.de/M7036910. Abgerufen am 20.11.2026.